Skip to main content
edited title
Link
user13628
user13628

What to do with older, highly voted, but wrong answeranswers?

Tweeted twitter.com/StackSpanish/status/986770749397590016
added 80 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
Diego Mod
  • 48.2k
  • 11
  • 25

I'm thinking about this question"What does “lo” in “(no) lo es” refer to?" 1 in particular, but it goes for any.

It's clear that some early answers despite being heavily voted up are actually wrong, but they've been accepted and likely the original questioner no longer uses the site.

Later, correct answers don't seem to ever get the level of upvoting which actually makes the question worse than not useful, it makes it a hazard for learners.

What is the best way to deal with these types of questions? Make a new question with a correct answer that's accepted, despite in effect falling afoul of the duplicate question issue?


1- asked 6 years, 4 months ago (at the time of writing this post)

I'm thinking about this question in particular, but it goes for any.

It's clear that some early answers despite being heavily voted up are actually wrong, but they've been accepted and likely the original questioner no longer uses the site.

Later, correct answers don't seem to ever get the level of upvoting which actually makes the question worse than not useful, it makes it a hazard for learners.

What is the best way to deal with these types of questions? Make a new question with a correct answer that's accepted, despite in effect falling afoul of the duplicate question issue?

I'm thinking about "What does “lo” in “(no) lo es” refer to?" 1 in particular, but it goes for any.

It's clear that some early answers despite being heavily voted up are actually wrong, but they've been accepted and likely the original questioner no longer uses the site.

Later, correct answers don't seem to ever get the level of upvoting which actually makes the question worse than not useful, it makes it a hazard for learners.

What is the best way to deal with these types of questions? Make a new question with a correct answer that's accepted, despite in effect falling afoul of the duplicate question issue?


1- asked 6 years, 4 months ago (at the time of writing this post)

Source Link

What to do with older, highly voted, but wrong answer

I'm thinking about this question in particular, but it goes for any.

It's clear that some early answers despite being heavily voted up are actually wrong, but they've been accepted and likely the original questioner no longer uses the site.

Later, correct answers don't seem to ever get the level of upvoting which actually makes the question worse than not useful, it makes it a hazard for learners.

What is the best way to deal with these types of questions? Make a new question with a correct answer that's accepted, despite in effect falling afoul of the duplicate question issue?